Choosing between Advanced Roofing Inc and Four Seasons Contracting comes down to whether you prioritize elite roofing certifications and long-term warranties or prefer a full-service contractor managing both exterior and interior projects.

This analysis helps homeowners and commercial property managers in the Chicago & Illinois regions evaluate reputable local contractors before hiring one.

Quick Verdict

Advanced Roofing Inc is best for quality-conscious customers focused specifically on roofing and exterior work who value manufacturer-backed warranties up to 50 years and working with an established, award-winning specialist. Four Seasons Contracting is best for homeowners needing comprehensive renovation services including interior remodeling and insurance restoration coordination.

If your priority is elite roofing certifications (GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed ShingleMaster) and a 30-year track record specifically in roofing, choose Advanced Roofing Inc. If you need one contractor to manage kitchens, bathrooms, and insurance claims alongside exterior work, choose Four Seasons Contracting.

Comparison Table

Dimension	Advanced Roofing Inc	Four Seasons Contracting
Primary Focus	Roofing and exterior systems specialist	Full-service restoration and remodeling
Years in Business	30+ years	Family-owned, established local presence
Key Certifications	GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed ShingleMaster, Owens Corning Preferred	Pella Certified Contractor, Malarkey Certified Contractor
Warranty Length	Up to 50 years on select systems	Up to 50 years on qualifying systems
Interior Services	No	Yes (kitchens, bathrooms, basements)
Insurance Restoration	Not emphasized	Specialized service with claims assistance
Workforce Model	In-house trained crews only	Coordinates all trades
BBB Rating	A+ since 2000	Accredited
Financing Options	Regions Bank (8.99%-24.49% APR, 12-month same-as-cash)	Not publicly disclosed
Google Rating	4.8/5 (195 reviews)	4.6/5 (21 reviews)

Overview of Advanced Roofing Inc

Advanced Roofing Inc has operated as a family-owned roofing and exterior systems contractor in the Chicagoland and Fox Valley area for over 30 years. The company positions itself with a “Quality Over Economy” approach, targeting customers who prioritize long-term roof performance and manufacturer certifications over low upfront costs.

Advanced Roofing holds elite certifications from GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning, enabling extended warranties up to 50 years. All work is performed by in-house trained crews with no subcontractors. The company has won consecutive “Best Roofing, Siding & Windows in Kendall County” awards from 2018 through 2025.

Overview of Four Seasons Contracting

Four Seasons Contracting operates as a family-owned, full-service restoration, renovation, and remodeling contractor serving the Fox Valley region including Sugar Grove, Naperville, Aurora, Yorkville, St. Charles, and Batavia. The company manages both exterior projects (roofing, siding, windows) and interior remodeling (kitchens, bathrooms, basements).

Four Seasons emphasizes transparency by linking directly to unfiltered third-party reviews and specializes in insurance restoration services, helping clients navigate claims after storm damage. The company holds manufacturer certifications with Pella and Malarkey, offering warranties up to 50 years on qualifying systems.

Certifications and Warranties Compared

Advanced Roofing Inc holds three elite manufacturer certifications: GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed ShingleMaster, and Owens Corning Preferred Contractor. These designations are awarded to fewer than 3% of roofing contractors nationally and require meeting strict standards for training, customer service, and financial stability. According to GAF’s certification criteria, Master Elite status enables contractors to offer the GAF Golden Pledge warranty covering both materials and workmanship for up to 50 years.

Four Seasons Contracting holds Pella Certified Contractor and Malarkey Certified Contractor designations. The Pella certification focuses on window installation expertise, while Malarkey certification covers roofing products. Both enable extended manufacturer warranties up to 50 years on qualifying installations. These certifications demonstrate competency across multiple product categories but do not carry the same roofing-specific prestige as GAF Master Elite status within the roofing industry.

For customers prioritizing the highest tier of roofing manufacturer backing, Advanced Roofing’s multiple elite certifications provide broader warranty options across premium shingle brands. For customers seeking certified expertise across windows and roofing within one contractor, Four Seasons offers cross-category manufacturer support.

Service Scope Compared

Advanced Roofing Inc specializes exclusively in exterior building envelope systems: roof repair and replacement, new commercial roofing, siding installation, gutter repair and replacement, and window replacement. The company uses premium materials from GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Tamko, and IKO. All installation work is performed by in-house crews rather than subcontractors, maintaining direct quality control. The company does not offer interior remodeling services.

Four Seasons Contracting provides a broader service range combining exterior work (roofing, siding, windows) with full interior remodeling including kitchen renovations, bathroom updates, and basement finishing. The company coordinates all necessary trades for complex renovation projects. Four Seasons also specializes in insurance restoration, assisting clients with damage assessment and claims documentation after storms or other covered events.

The service scope difference is substantial. If your project is limited to roofing and exterior improvements, both companies are qualified. If you are planning a whole-home renovation combining a new roof with kitchen or bathroom remodeling, Four Seasons provides single-point project management. If you prefer working with a specialized roofing contractor who focuses exclusively on building envelope systems, Advanced Roofing offers deeper expertise in that specific domain.

Customer Reviews and Reputation Compared

Advanced Roofing Inc maintains a strong 4.8/5 rating on Google. The company has held BBB A+ accreditation since 2000. Advanced Roofing claims over 150 five-star reviews across platforms. Positive reviews frequently mention professional crews, thorough cleanup, on-time arrival, and strong communication. Negative reviews cite responsiveness delays during peak seasons, project timeline communication issues, and isolated workmanship complaints with less effective resolution.

Four Seasons Contracting holds a 4.4/5 rating on Yelp based on 7 reviews. The company is BBB accredited, though it has limited presence on major national contractor review platforms like HomeAdvisor, Angi, or Houzz. Reviews emphasize quality craftsmanship, professionalism, and a family-oriented service approach. Some reviews mention occasional communication lapses, particularly coordinating with ownership.

Advanced Roofing benefits from a significantly larger review volume, providing more statistical reliability, though the Yelp rating disparity warrants attention. The 195 verified reviews on Google represent a substantial track record. Four Seasons’ smaller review count reflects either newer platform adoption or lower review solicitation, and the 4.4/5 Yelp average from actual customers is notable compared to Advanced Roofing’s diminished presence on the same platform.

According to reviewer comments on both platforms, Advanced Roofing customers most frequently praise warranty options and manufacturer relationships, while Four Seasons customers most frequently praise transparency and family business character.

Pricing Compared

Neither company publishes pricing tiers publicly. Both require site visits and consultations for project-specific estimates.

Advanced Roofing Inc offers financing through Regions Bank with two options: traditional installment loans ranging from 8.99% to 24.49% APR based on creditworthiness, and a 12-month same-as-cash promotional plan with 19.99% APR applied if not paid within the promotional period. The company also advertises a senior discount, though the specific percentage is not disclosed.

Four Seasons Contracting does not publicly disclose financing partnerships or payment plan options. Prospective clients must request this information during the free consultation process.

For customers who value transparent financing information before initial contact, Advanced Roofing provides more upfront clarity. For customers preferring to discuss all financial options during a personalized consultation, both companies operate on similar models.

Where Four Seasons Contracting Wins

Comprehensive project management for multi-scope renovations. If your project combines roofing with interior work like kitchen or bathroom remodeling, Four Seasons manages all trades from start to finish under one contract. This eliminates coordination burdens between separate contractors for exterior and interior work.

Insurance restoration expertise. Four Seasons specializes in navigating insurance claims after storm damage, providing damage assessment documentation and working directly with adjusters. This service is particularly valuable for customers dealing with hail, wind, or water damage requiring both repairs and insurance reimbursement.

Higher Yelp rating from actual customers. Four Seasons’ 4.4/5 Yelp rating, while based on fewer reviews, reflects consistently positive customer experiences on a platform where dissatisfied customers are more likely to post. This suggests strong satisfaction among recent clients willing to share feedback publicly.

Transparent review philosophy. Four Seasons directly links to unfiltered third-party reviews on their website and encourages prospective clients to read all feedback, including negative comments. This approach builds trust through radical transparency rather than selective testimonial curation.

Where Advanced Roofing Inc Wins

Elite manufacturer certifications across multiple premium brands. Advanced Roofing holds GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed ShingleMaster, and Owens Corning Preferred certifications. These designations require meeting strict performance standards and enable the strongest manufacturer-backed warranties available in residential roofing. Only 3% of roofing contractors qualify for GAF Master Elite status nationally.

30-year track record with documented community recognition. Advanced Roofing has operated for over three decades and won “Best Roofing, Siding & Windows in Kendall County” awards consecutively from 2018 through 2025. This longevity and sustained local recognition demonstrate consistent performance over multiple business cycles and ownership transitions in the local market.

Substantially larger verified review volume. With 195 reviews on Google, maintaining a 4.8/5 rating and BBB A+ accreditation since 2000, Advanced Roofing provides statistically significant evidence of customer satisfaction over an extended period. The volume allows prospective clients to read diverse project experiences rather than relying on a handful of testimonials.

In-house crew model with no subcontractors. All installation work is performed by Advanced Roofing’s trained employees rather than subcontracted labor. This provides direct quality control, consistent training standards, and clearer accountability. Customers work with the same company from estimate through warranty service.

Publicly disclosed financing with multiple options. Advanced Roofing provides specific APR ranges and promotional terms upfront through their Regions Bank partnership, plus a senior discount. This transparency allows customers to pre-qualify for financial feasibility before scheduling estimates.

If you’re focused on long-term roofing performance, it may be worth speaking with Advanced Roofing Inc to understand which certified system best fits your home.

Project Timeline and Communication Compared

Customer reviews for Advanced Roofing Inc mention both positive and negative experiences with timeline communication. Several reviewers on Experience.com praise on-time project starts and efficient completion.

Four Seasons Contracting reviews on Yelp and Google mention occasional communication challenges coordinating with ownership, though overall project execution receives praise. The broader service scope involving interior trades may create additional coordination complexity compared to exterior-only projects.

Neither company demonstrates consistent communication issues severe enough to disqualify them, but prospective clients should set clear expectations during the contracting phase regarding update frequency, permit timelines, and weather delay protocols.

Commercial vs. Residential Focus Compared

Advanced Roofing Inc serves both residential homeowners and commercial property owners or managers. The company specifically markets commercial roofing services emphasizing code compliance and long-term maintenance partnerships. Their website includes dedicated commercial service pages. However, one detailed review from a commercial client cited significant timeline and communication issues on a commercial project, suggesting possible inconsistency in commercial project management.

Four Seasons Contracting primarily markets to residential customers, with commercial services available but not prominently featured. The company’s emphasis on family-owned character and home renovation messaging skews toward residential homeowners.

For commercial property managers requiring specialized commercial roofing expertise, Advanced Roofing offers more explicitly positioned services, though requesting references from similar commercial clients is advisable given the mixed commercial feedback.

What Users Say

Advanced Roofing Inc customers on Experience.com consistently mention professional installation crews, thorough job site cleanup, and strong manufacturer warranty offerings. Representative positive feedback includes: “The crew was professional and completed the job efficiently” and “They explained all warranty options clearly.” Critical feedback on Yelp includes: “Took weeks to get an estimate during summer” and “Project timeline changed multiple times without clear explanation.”

Four Seasons Contracting customers on Yelp emphasize trustworthiness, quality work, and treating projects like their own home. Representative feedback includes: “They were transparent about everything and did excellent work” and “Managed our whole renovation seamlessly.” Critical comments mention occasional difficulty reaching ownership for decisions. The 4.4/5 Yelp rating from 7 reviews suggests positive experiences of customers who chose to leave public reviews.

Recent Business Developments

Advanced Roofing Inc experienced a significant transition in May 2026 with the passing of the company owner, causing temporary office closure. This represents a meaningful operational moment that may affect near-term responsiveness and project capacity during the ownership transition. The company updated financing terms in March 2026, adjusting the 12-month same-as-cash plan to a fixed 19.99% APR after the promotional period. Advanced Roofing continued winning local awards through 2025 and refreshed website content with expanded service area information.

Four Seasons Contracting has not announced significant operational changes, new service lines, or pricing restructuring in the past 12 months based on publicly available information.

Prospective customers considering Advanced Roofing should inquire about current operational status and leadership continuity following the May 2026 transition to ensure project management stability.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Advanced Roofing Inc if:

• Your project is specifically roofing, siding, gutters, or windows with no interior work
• You prioritize elite manufacturer certifications (GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed ShingleMaster, Owens Corning Preferred) and the strongest available warranties
• You value a 30-year track record with consecutive local awards and BBB A+ accreditation since 2000
• You prefer working with in-house trained crews rather than coordinated subcontractors
• You want upfront financing information with multiple options before the estimate appointment
• You are a quality-conscious customer willing to pay premium prices for long-term roof performance

Choose Four Seasons Contracting if:

• Your project combines exterior work (roofing, siding, windows) with interior remodeling (kitchen, bathroom, basement)
• You need insurance restoration services with claims documentation and adjuster coordination
• You value a family-owned business approach with transparent review policies
• You prefer one contractor managing all trades for comprehensive renovations
• You prioritize Pella window certification or Malarkey roofing certification specifically
• You want a contractor with higher recent Yelp ratings from actual customers

If you are in the Illinois region planning a multi-room renovation involving both a new roof and interior updates, Four Seasons Contracting eliminates the need to coordinate separate contractors. If you are focused exclusively on maximizing roof longevity with top-tier manufacturer backing, Advanced Roofing Inc provides deeper roofing-specific expertise and more elite certifications.

Both companies offer manufacturer-backed warranties up to 50 years on qualifying systems. The fundamental decision comes down to specialized roofing depth versus full-service renovation breadth.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which company offers better roofing warranties?

Both Advanced Roofing Inc and Four Seasons Contracting offer manufacturer-backed warranties up to 50 years on qualifying systems. Advanced Roofing holds elite certifications with GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning, providing warranty options across more premium shingle brands. Four Seasons holds Malarkey certification. The warranty strength depends on the specific product chosen, but Advanced Roofing’s GAF Master Elite status enables the GAF Golden Pledge warranty, which covers both materials and workmanship.

Do either of these contractors handle insurance claims?

Four Seasons Contracting specializes in insurance restoration services, including damage assessment documentation and coordination with insurance adjusters after storms or covered events. Advanced Roofing Inc does not prominently market insurance restoration services, focusing primarily on planned roof replacement and repair projects.

Which company has better customer reviews?

Advanced Roofing Inc has significantly more review volume, with 4.8/5 Google rating and BBB A+ accreditation since 2000. However, on Yelp, Advanced Roofing doesn’t have any significant presence compared to Four Seasons’ 4.4/5 (7 reviews). The larger Google sample provides more statistical reliability, but the Yelp disparity suggests some customers experienced service gaps. Four Seasons has fewer total reviews but higher scores on the platform where negative experiences are more commonly shared.

Can either company handle both my roof and kitchen remodel?

Four Seasons Contracting manages both exterior and interior projects, including kitchens, bathrooms, and basements alongside roofing work. Advanced Roofing Inc specializes exclusively in exterior building envelope systems (roofing, siding, gutters, windows) and does not offer interior remodeling services.

Which company is better for commercial roofing projects?

Advanced Roofing Inc explicitly markets commercial roofing services with emphasis on code compliance and maintenance partnerships. However, at least one detailed commercial client review cited timeline and communication issues. Four Seasons Contracting primarily focuses on residential customers with commercial services available but not prominently featured. For commercial projects, request references from similar commercial clients from whichever contractor you are considering.

Do both companies use in-house crews or subcontractors?

Advanced Roofing Inc performs all work with in-house trained employees and explicitly states no subcontractors are used. Four Seasons Contracting coordinates all necessary trades for comprehensive renovations, which typically involves managing specialized subcontractors for different scopes (electrical, plumbing, etc.) under their project management.